Mister J's

Apollo De Jesus a month ago

Good times. It was legit Chicago style local stuff we have been looking for. Just taste the culture the vibe and absolutely love it. So good, so fresh and would definitely come back. We just visit from Texas and this is the stuff we look for.

Lindsey 7 months ago

Took a 4 day trip to Chicago and this was the best Italian beef that I could find!!! Service was better than any of the other restaurants/stores we went to while we were here. Family running the front counter were extremely helpful, courteous, and gave a bunch of “thank you’s” to us. Food was excellent, affordable, and fresh. Couldn’t have asked for a better experience while coming to Chicago. This Texan will be back next summer when it’s less cold!!

etcTrent 10 months ago

the food was so bad that after taking one bite we all got boxes and walked out. then we left the boxes on a dumpster for some desperate soul. we then went to The Hat, where we ordered the exact same items, and had an incredible late night junk food experience. may God have mercy on all souls who dare enter Mr. J's domain.

Delia Rigney a month ago

There were small flying insects all over the tables and ceilings and landing on our food. My fries were bland, the cheese sauce didn’t even help, and the mozzarella sticks barely had a cheese pull or any crisp to the breading. The marinara was watery and also bland. I am vegetarian… maybe the other food is good but the bugs are gross and being that it was the dining area I don’t wanna know what is in the kitchen. The people watching is worth the price of admission. Don’t look at the ceiling if you want to finish your meal. Grateful to have something for my friend to eat at midnight… she liked her grilled chicken sandwich.

Blue B a year ago

Mr. J's in Chicago is one of those spots that lands squarely in the "it's just okay" category. It's not going to blow your mind, but it also won't leave you regretting your choice. The ambiance is pretty standard, leaning towards a casual, no-frills diner feel. You won't find any trendy decor or unique design elements here; it's clean and functional, perfect for a quick, unpretentious meal. The service is usually prompt and efficient, getting your food out without much fuss, though don't expect overly warm or memorable interactions. They get the job done. Now, for the food. We tried a couple of their popular dishes. The burger was decent, cooked to order with standard toppings, but nothing that made it stand out from a dozen other places. The fries were hot and crispy, which is always a plus. We also sampled their pizza puff, a Chicago staple. It was exactly what you'd expect: a deep-fried, crispy shell filled with molten cheese and savory sausage, satisfying in a greasy-spoon kind of way. It was edible and hit the spot for that particular craving, but it wasn't anything elevated or particularly memorable compared to others around the city. Portion sizes are generous, so you definitely get your money's worth in terms of quantity. The prices are fair, reflecting the straightforward nature of the food and experience. Mr. J's feels like a dependable fallback when you're hungry and nearby, but not somewhere you'd go out of your way to visit. It's perfectly average, a reliable spot for a quick bite without any high expectations.